Online communities, online safety & young people: our policy perspective

This policy summary is part of a series setting out the major changes that are needed to improve mental health. It draws upon Mental Health Foundation research and analysis which can be found in the 'further reading' section.  

The recommendations in this paper are for England, though many are also applicable to the other nations of the UK; some, including those on online safety, apply to the whole of the UK. 

 Contents

Why does online safety matter for mental health? 

For many people, more of our lives than ever before are being spent online, with the average UK adult now spending 4 hours and 20 minute online every day.1

Some of that time spent online will be spent in ‘communities’ – a term by which we mean any online spaces where people engage with others. There are different ways to engage with communities: much of the evidence on helpful online communities is around people actively taking part in communities by sharing their experiences and commenting on those of others.2 On the other hand, we know that the impact of harmful communities can extend beyond those who actively engage, to those who just read or view material. Some of the places we find online communities are: 

  • Social media (like Instagram, Snapchat, X/Twitter, Facebook)
  • Messaging groups (like WhatsApp or Discord)
  • Forums and online groups (like Reddit, Mumsnet, Digital Spy, Steam, or gaming servers)
  • Website comment sections
  • Influencer followings
  • Video platforms (like YouTube, Twitch, or TikTok)

For many of us, online communities enrich our lives, bring us joy, and help us to find comfort in difficult times. They allow us to make friends, explore hobbies, connect with people who share our own identities and ways of thinking, and learn from those who do not.

But there are darker online communities too. There are ones that incite vicious racism of the type we saw in the summer riots of 20243, and that promote misogyny, antisemitism and other forms of hatred. And there are communities that promote self-harm, eating disorders, and suicide. All of these are bad for our mental health in various ways. 

We all have a part to play in protecting ourselves and those around us from the worst the online world has to offer. Education on this topic, both self-taught and taught by others, is essential.

Online safety education: the evidence

Online communities can be a real source of positive relationships, which we know are one of the key building blocks of good mental health.

For those who get involved in communities based on hatred, focusing on hate over kindness is likely to worsen mental health  , and also have real-world consequences when they act on their beliefs. We know the immense toll being the target of hate and discrimination takes on victims’ mental health.4  And, of course, communities which encourage self-harm, eating disorders and suicide can have very real impacts for those involved in them. 5,6    

Evidence: Young people's experiences

In April 2025, the Mental Health Foundation undertook polling of 2157 young people aged 16 – 21, to find out more about their experiences of accessing harmful content online.

We found incredibly high levels of access to online communities. Most young people (98%) access at least one online community every day – with more than half doing so several times an hour (57%).

Young people reported making valuable connections through online communities. Around three quarters (76%) of young people reported feeling very or somewhat connected with others through online communities, and two thirds (63%) said they’d been in an online community which had made them feel more confident or supported in who they are.

The findings however also highlighted that most young people had been exposed to harmful or disturbing content online, with almost 7 in 10 young people (68%) having seen disturbing or harmful content online. More than a third of young people had seen suicide or self-harm content (35%), and more than a quarter had also been exposed to pro-eating disorder content online (28%).

Other forms of harmful online content were also prevalent – over two fifths of young people had been exposed to bullying (40%) or racist/discriminatory content (42%).

Among those who had felt unsafe due to content they saw online, two thirds (65%) said social media had made them feel this way, and one third (32%) said messaging groups – like Discord or WhatsApp – had done the same. 

When asked to name a particular online community that had made individuals feel unsafe, the most common examples given were on Snapchat (19%), TikTok (14%), Instagram (13%), Discord (12%), Reddit (11%) and X/Twitter (8%). It is worth noting that, of these answers, all except X/Twitter were also featured in the list of young people’s favourite online communities. 

Evidence: Schools

Positively, we know from work carried out by the Children’s Commissioner that most children report having had lessons about how to stay safe online.7 There are also encouraging signs that Relationships, Sex and Health Education (RSHE) standards and consistency have improved since the statutory RSHE requirement was introduced in 2020.8

However, the polling we undertook in April 2025 found that 10% of young people aged 16-21 received no online safety education at all. Among those who did, nearly three in five (58%) found it was not helpful enough or helpful at all. 

This is of real concern given that 76% of secondary school teachers and 60% of primary school teachers have reported that they were extremely concerned about the influence of online misogyny in their schools.9

Core principles and approach

  • Online communities now form a key part of our relationships, and like relationships that take place offline, these are essential for our mental health. We need to take a public health approach to making sure the online world is as safe for young people’s mental health as can be.
  • Much of the damage done to our mental health in society, and by extension in online communities, is driven by commercial practice. Governments, regulators and corporations themselves have a role in protecting us from this harm. In recognition of the challenges of regulating the social media sector, we believe schools and parents need to be supported to ‘plug the gap,’ while regulation is lacking or poorly enforced.
  • Young people cannot be excluded from the online world until their late teens. Our online existence will play a huge role in everyone’s lives, and children who do not have access to it until later in their youth are likely to face challenges if they are suddenly exposed to the vast and complex internet.
  • As young people will have access to online spaces, education, in particular schools, are best placed to support young people with healthy use of the internet and participation in online communities, just as we encourage schools to teach children about relationships, democracy, sex, narcotics, personal economics and other elements of society.
     

Recommendations for action

As an emerging area of policy, there are a number of ways that positive change can be achieved in this area. We have chosen to focus on how the government can support schools, actions the schools and parents can take, and advice for users to protect themselves:

How the government can promote engaging with online communities safely through schools:

  • The government should update guidance on teaching on emerging threats and problematic online communities, and develop resources in this area for teachers. This would be taught through PSHE (Physical, Social, Health and Economic education).
  • Right now, the materials to support teaching about online safety can be out of date, if it is taught at all.  The government should look to work with voluntary sector organisations, including those working on mental health and against hatred, to enhance the materials provided to teachers to support the teaching of online safety in PHSE.
  • Guidance on the Relationships, Sex and Health Education element of PSHE, which is the only mandatory element of the subject, should make more explicit reference to the threats that exist online and in online communities specifically.
  • Government should use the upcoming review of statutory guidance on PSHE to advance this, and it should also be considered as part of the government’s curriculum review which is currently under way.
The Online Safety Act
  • Ofcom has made the decision that it will not regulate the most dangerous small forums, such as suicide, eating disorder and hate forums, at the highest level possible under the Online Safety Act, which The Department for Science, Innovation and Technology has accepted. This must be urgently reversed, so that these small but very harmful communities are held to the same standard as household name services (like Facebook, Instagram and X/Twitter.)
  • Schools should ensure that they are fully implementing the non-statutory guidance ‘Teaching Online Safety in Schools’ and teaching according to the ‘Education for a Connected World’ framework.
  • Schools should follow the PSHE Association’s Programme of Study (key stages 1–5), including area relevant to supporting young people to understand online communities, staying safe online and avoiding dangerous online influence.10 They can also make use of the PSHE Association lesson pack 'Belonging and community: addressing discrimination and extremism' which helps children and young people to develop their understanding of discrimination and extremism.11
  • Schools should take a whole school approach to teaching online safety. For example, they should consider discussing radicalisation and the political and social currents that sit behind hate groups in humanities subjects like English or History.
  • Mental Health Support Teams should be aware of the dangers and benefits of the online world and able to discuss these with pupils, including the types of communities they are part of.
  • Talk to your children about what groups they’re part of online. You could explore the following questions:
    • Do they feel safe?
    • Does the community hold everyone accountable?
    • Do they feel connected to others?
    • Does it align with their values and who they are as a person?
    • Does it drain them or make them feel bad about themselves?12
    • Does it make them feel hateful or discriminatory towards other people/groups of people?
  • Look into what parental controls are available, or whether apps allow you to see what your children are seeing. But remember that technological solutions are no substitute for curiosity and engagement; they’re also imperfect and can often be sidestepped.
  • The NSPCC has tips on how to talk to children about online safety, and advice on difficult issues like what to do if you suspect grooming.
  • Finding online connection around any hobby or interest can help our mental health. But activities we know are particularly good for mental health include spending time in nature, exercise, and creative pursuits. Combining these interests with a healthy online community could protect and improve your mental health.
    • There’s nothing wrong with communities that are only online, but in-person connection offers advantages too. The sorts of communities that could benefit your mental health the most might span the online and offline worlds, allowing you to realise the advantages of both forms of interactions.
  • Be aware that communities can change over time and become unhelpful, and interests in harmless topics can sometimes lead to damaging communities. Examples would be the way there can be an overlap between holistic wellness communities and ones which push unscientific conspiracy theories, or ones that support self-growth overlapping with hateful ideologies.
  • Think about what you don’t want to interact with. Stay away from content, creators, influencers, or people who make you feel bad about yourself or uncomfortable. It’s always OK to block, unfollow, report, or mute others to protect yourself online.
  • Pay attention to how you feel when you engage in a community. How does being a part of your community make you feel? Are you anxious, angry, or sad? A healthy community should make you feel connected, respected, and accepted.
  • Think about your reasons for wanting to be part of a community. Why do you want to be a part of this space? What do you want to learn or gain from this community?

Last Updated: May 2025. For review: May 2026.

[1] Online Nation 2024 Report, Ofcom, http://www.ofcom.org.uk/siteassets/resources/documents/research-and-data/online-research/online-nation/2024/online-nation-2024-report.pdf?v=386238, last accessed 1 May 2025

[2] See, for example: Shelly Rodgers, Qimei Chen, ‘Internet Community Group Participation:Psychosocial Benefits for Women with Breast Cancer’, Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication, Volume 10, Issue 4, 1 July 2005, JCMC1047, http://doi.org/10.1111/j.1083-6101.2005.tb00268.x

[3] Zara Mohammed, Oral evidence: Social media, misinformation and harmful algorithms, HC 441, (21 January 2025.) Accessed at: http://committees.parliament.uk/oralevidence/15274/pdf/

[4] Stephanie Wallace, James Nazroo, Laia Bécares, “Cumulative Effect of Racial Discrimination on the Mental Health of Ethnic Minorities in the United Kingdom”, American Journal of Public Health 106, no. 7 (July 1, 2016): pp. 1294-1300. http://doi.org/10.2105/AJPH.2016.303121

[5] Codie R. Rouleau, Kristin M. von Ranson, Potential risks of pro-eating disorder websites, Clinical Psychology Review, Volume 31, Issue 4, 2011, pp. 525-531, ISSN 0272-7358, http://doi.org/10.1016/j.cpr.2010.12.005.

[6] Crawford, A, Smith T (2023), ‘'Failure to act' on suicide website linked to 50 UK deaths’, BBC News, 24 October 2023, Retrieved 2 May 2025 from: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-67082224.

[7] Office of the Children’s Commissioner (2023). Children and RSHE. Retrieved 13 April 2025 from: http://www.childrenscommissioner.gov.uk/blog/children-and-rshe/

[8] PSHE Association (2025) Statutory RSHE impact: keeping more children safe through education. Retrieved 13 April 2025 from http://pshe-association.org.uk/news/how-youre-keeping-children-safe-through-education

[9] Over, Harriet orcid.org/0000-0001-9461-043X, Bunce, Carl James, Baggaley, Jonathan et al. (2025) Understanding the influence of online misogyny in schools from the perspective of teachers. PLoS ONE. ISSN 1932-6203

[10] PSHE Association (2020). Programme of Study (key stages 1-5). Retrieved 13 April 2025 from: http://pshe-association.org.uk/guidance/ks1-5/planning/long-term-planning

[11] PSHE Association (n.d.) Belonging and community: addressing discrimination and extremism. Retrieved 13 April 2025 from: http://pshe-association.org.uk/resource/belonging-and-community

[12] These recommendations are adapted from those published by Mental Health America: http://www.mhanational.org/youth-tech/find-healthy-online-communities